Pub Musician, Worship Musician?

Can someone who is playing at a pub or a rock band also play in the worship team?

The question seems to boil down to whether playing in a pub or rock band disqualifies someone from playing in the worship team. I've done my own pub-band time and other secular gigs as well, so here are three things that I'd look at when it comes to this issue.

Alcohol – Does the person have a problem with alcohol abuse? If so then he/she ought to avoid the pub environment in the first place.

Eph 5:18 - Do not get drunk on wine, which leads to debauchery. Instead, be filled with the Spirit (NIV)

I have no problems with believers drinking alcohol. If the Bible does not prohibit it, neither should I. But the Bible DOES prohibit getting drunk. So if we are talking about a believer who plays music at a pub and he or she consistently gets drunk, then I'd think twice about letting this person play on the worship team.

Secular music – I also have no problem with believers playing secular music. The Bible does not prohibit it, neither should I. But the Bible does speak out against confusing the sacred with the secular. Consider this passage:

Eze 33:31-32 - So they come to you as people do, they sit before you as My people, and they hear your words, but they do not do them; for with their mouth they show much love, but their hearts pursue their own gain. Indeed you are to them as a very lovely song of one who has a pleasant voice and can play well on an instrument; for they hear your words, but they do not do them. (NKJV)

The reference to secular entertainers in Israel shows that they did exist in those days. In this passage, God says that ignoring the word of a prophet is like treating him/her just like a secular entertainer. The Bible does not condemn secular music, but it does tell us not to treat the Word of God in the same way, as mere entertainment.

The Believer's Word Life – And that refers to both the time the person spends in the Bible and his spoken words.

A secular pub is usually an unedifying place. The Bible does not give us a definite order to avoid all unedifying places, in fact we are told that the whole world is under the control of the evil one (1 John 5:19). So that means that we cannot totally avoid unedifying places. But we CAN keep ourselves from being polluted by the world (James 1:27). And that is what we should aim for.

So if a pub or rock musician wants to play on the worship team, my first question is this: has he or she been polluted by the world? The fastest gauge of that is his or her speech, because the mouth speaks what the heart is full of (Luke 6:45). If the believer has been polluted by the world, his or her speech will usually be the first to go haywire.

Quick tip: don't just listen to how this person talks in church. Drop by the pub when this musician is working, hide yourself one corner and pay careful attention to how he or she behaves when no one knows you are around. There are pub musicians I know who consistently shine forth as lights in a warped and crooked generation (Phi 2:15), even at the pub itself. I'd be honoured to have those people with me on the worship team anytime!

I'll also watch for this person's hunger for the Word of God. Why? Because if his or her heart has departed from the LORD, he/she will lose the hunger for the Bible.

Jeremiah 2:15 - My people have committed two sins: They have forsaken me, the spring of living water, and have dug their own cisterns, broken cisterns that cannot hold water. (NIV)

And once the hunger for the Word of God is gone, the pollution of the world will come in very quickly. So does the musician in question skip church services? How is his/her personal time in the Word of God? I'd ask what was the latest insight he/she got from the Scriptures recently. If you see a panic-stricken expression on the face, that's a warning sign for you right there!

Conclusion: Every believer will have areas in life where they need help. A believer who is pub or rock band musician and who has any of the above problems is NOT a lesser person in Christ than we are. They just need help in those areas, just as we ourselves do in other parts of our lives. If a pub or rock band musician has problems with alcohol abuse and with being polluted by the world, then whether he/she is included on the worship team is a decision that is best made by the pastor in charge. Why? Because the LORD may use the musician's involvement in worship ministry to spur him/her to take God seriously. Because the ramifications are heavier than usual, it is best to leave this decision to God-appointed leadership who will pray and seek the mind of God on this situation.

Let me know what you think?

The Fish With A Coin In The Mouth

I am a charismatic. And proud of it.

But there are times when I cringe at what some of my fellow charismatics do. And that is especially when they make a very uniquely charismatic mistake, to mess up the natural and expect the supernatural to compensate for it.

What do I mean by that?

One clear example are people who claim they want to play drums for worship, refuse to seriously learn the instrument, and yet pray fervently that God would anoint their playing and bless the worship session with his presence. They would talk about depending on the Lord and not on their own efforts, not have the fruits to back it up, and then accuse others of being fleshly and earthly-minded if they do not agree that they are anointed and gifted of God in their drumming.

This mistake can manifest in other ways and contexts, other than just worship ministry. For example, a church may be seeking to hire a pastoral assistant with at least a diploma in theology, and yet put up the job notice in only one place – a secular job site. Surely if they wanted to seek the people with the right qualifications, they would at least email the notice to a few Bible Colleges or seminaries, right? They didn't.

I don't see this kind of mistake among the non-charismatics.
What makes the whole thing confusing?
You see, amongst us charismatics, we have testimonies of God directing people to do things that do not make sense, and yet they get results. Supernatural results.

All that is great – until we feed people the expectation that God will usually work like that, or if we believe that taking care of the natural details leaves God no room to work supernaturally. And for many of us charismatics, that has been put to us as the unpardonable sin, moving in the flesh, trusting in the arm of man rather than the power of God.

During this season I have been meditating on the Gospel of Matthew, and one day this verse grabbed my attention.
But so that we may not offend them, go to the lake and throw out your line. Take the first fish you catch; open its mouth and you will find a four-drachma coin. Take it and give it to them for my tax and yours. (Matthew 17:27, NIV)
Jesus said this after Peter had foolishly committed himself and Jesus to paying the temple tax. Jesus, being the rightful owner of the temple (and the rest of the entire universe) of course would be exempted from the tax. But because Jesus saw the whole thing as a small matter, not worth offending the Pharisees over, he chose to pay that tax in a supernatural way.

Can you imagine what the other disciples might have said to Peter as he was heading off to follow Jesus' instructions?

"Hey Peter, I heard about the temple tax people coming here just now. What happened?"
"I told them that Jesus would pay the temple tax."

"And how does Jesus intend to settle that?"

"He told me to go fishing."

"Want some help, Peter? Maybe John and James should go help you? You are going to need to catch a lot of fish to pay that tax!"

"No problem, Jesus said I only need to get one, because the first one will have the money in its mouth already!"

Wonder what the other disciples thought at this point!

What I JUST noticed, however, was Jesus took care of the natural factors as well. What do I mean? For example, Jesus sent Peter to fish for the money, not Matthew the Tax Collector or Simon the Zealot. Naturally speaking, Peter was well-qualified to perform this task.

Jesus also directed Peter to fish in the lake. That was the ideal and reasonable place for Peter to find fish. Jesus could have told him to go fish in a river or pond or even look for the fish somewhere on land, since God would have no difficulty moving fish around anywhere he wishes. And yet Jesus told Peter to go to the lake.
In other words, we see that, even when preparing for a supernatural work, Jesus would get qualified people to go to the right places for it!
Of course God can direct his people to do really weird things. It's his prerogative. Personally, if someone tells me that God told him or her to do something strange, and if everything goes horribly wrong I am the person cleaning up the mess, then I'll look for the following two signs that this person has been directed by God:

1) Timing: Notice from this account that the first fish gave Peter the results. If Peter had to catch 2,385 fish to find that one fish with the money inside, then I'll say that his finding the money was just a fluke. Things like that happen.

2) Leverage: Could Peter have paid the tax without the money in the fish's mouth? Yes, but it would take catching a lot more fish! What was supernatural in this incidence was the leverage and impact of the results. This one fish was enough to accomplish God's purpose when usually we would need a lot more fish. If Peter toiled for a couple of weeks to catch enough fish for the tax, we can see clearly that it was not a supernatural working.

There are different ways leverage can be manifested. For example, in Luke 5:1-11, Peter caught a huge number of fish (leverage) immediately upon the Word of Jesus (timing). In Matthew 17 Jesus chose to skip the necessity of selling the fish in exchange for money and used the fish to bring the money directly. And after this account, the next time Jesus gave Peter a supernatural catch of fish in John 21, the leverage was displayed through the huge number of fish again.

So I'll look for the signs. Such as a job-ad in an unusual place pulling in the right job candidates immediately, or an untrained musician being able to play what unifies the worship of the congregation. In other words, I will judge, not by the jargon or spiritual-sounding clichés the person uses, but by the fruits (Luke 6:44).

Why would a person choose to ignore the natural factors and principles that make things work?

Ultimately it is an issue of slothfulness.

The sluggard is wiser in his own eyes than seven men who answer discreetly. (Pro 26:16, NIV)

Those who are mentally lazy and do not want to put in the necessary preparations like to think of themselves as being above the rules. They want to believe that they can get results without putting in the necessary effort. And they use the Holy Spirit as an excuse.

For example, I see some business websites that are set up by Christians, and those sites have HORRIBLE marketing copy on them. The writing that they put up is self-indulgent and totally devoid of marketing value. It will not bring them customers; in fact, it will probably drive the customers away. Those website owners can say that they are inspired by God to write what they wrote, but if it isn't bringing them the results, then they are indirectly blaming God for the lack of fruit.

The willingness to learn what is necessary and do what it takes is the difference between the mentally lazy and the serious people who just need more time to bear fruit. Those who are serious but just need more time are those who will consult with genuine experts (not just friends, neighbours and relatives) and put in genuine effort.

They are teachable but discerning. They know that they are better off getting marketing advice from a marketing expert (with proven sales results), worship ministry advice from an effective worship leader, and exercise and diet advice from someone who is healthy and full of energy.

In other words, they will make themselves into the right people and are willing to go to the right places. When their time comes they are ready for God to use their natural preparations and give them supernatural results. Just like Peter in Matthew 17.

Please hear my heart. I know what I share here will be controversial, and there will be sincere, God-fearing charismatics who are offended by what I have said. But I am sharing this so that:

1) You will recognize this kind of faulty thinking in other people;

2) You will avoid it for yourself; AND

3) You will put in the necessary effort to make yourself the right person who can go to the right places at God's direction and be blessed with supernatural results.

I will not know what is God's specific assignment and direction for your life. It may or may not be in the worship ministry. But what I can tell you is that whatever it is, it will require you to grow in your understanding and skills. And it will involve a lot of mundane, unexciting preparations. Just like in Peter's case, when all the fishing he did before using his own natural abilities helped prepare him to be someone God could use to fish supernaturally.

So be patient, be faithful, and one day you may be the one opening the fish's mouth to find a coin inside!
"May the God of peace… equip you with everything good for doing his will" (Hebrews 13:20, 21 NIV)
P.S. And if you want to get equipped to serve God in the worship ministry and you haven't got my book yet, what are you waiting for? Get it, get equipped and get going!